Water Supply Vol 2 No 2 pp 11–18 © IWA Publishing 2002
A systems analysis comparing drinking water systems - central physical-chemical treatment and local membrane filtration
T. Westrell*, O. Bergstedt**, G. Heinicke*** and E. Kärrman****
*Department of Water and Environmental Studies, University of Linköping, SE-581 83 Linköping, Sweden. (E-mail: therese.westrell@tema.liu.se)
**The Recycling Board, City of Göteborg, P.O. Box 11192, SE-404 24 Göteborg, Sweden and Water Environment Transport, Chalmers University of Technology, Göteborg, Sweden. (E-mail: olof.bergstedt@krets.goteborg.se)
***Water Environment Transport, Chalmers University of Technology, SE-412 96 Göteborg, Sweden. (E-mail: gerald.heinicke@wet.chalmers.se)
****Scandiaconsult Sverige AB, Stockholm, P.O. Box 4205, SE-102 65 Stockholm, Sweden. (E-mail: erik.karrman@scc.se)
ABSTRACT
This paper presents a first attempt at an integrated systems analysis of drinking water systems using Microbiological Risk Assessment (MRA) and Material Flow Analysis (MFA) with focus on the comparison of central physical-chemical treatment (conventional system) and local membrane filtration. The MFA shows that energy use is the most significant environmental impact of the three studied drinking water systems, but there are no considerable differences in energy use comparing central physical-chemical treatment and local membrane filtration. According to the MRA, the conventional system might not reduce the microbial risks sufficiently, but such a reduction can not confidently be achieved in a one-step ultrafiltration system either, since membrane filter integrity can hardly be guaranteed over the service life of the equipment. A quite costly two-step membrane filtration system, where water for all household purposes passes microfiltration and further reverse osmosis for drinking and cooking, seems to fulfil this criterion. On the other hand, this system does not reduce the microbial risks from ingestion of water from showers compared with the one-step ultrafiltration alternative. In order to achieve drinking water systems with sufficient microbial barriers and with reasonable costs for operation, a promising solution seems to be a combination of one-step membrane filtration and other methods e.g. biological treatment.
Full article (PDF Format)
PAY-PER-VIEW: Buy this article for £20.00 (IWA MEMBER PRICE: £15.00)
|
